A Harbor of Deceit: A Gilded Age Tale of Money, Murder, and Madness
"On October 6, 1885, in Gilded Age Newport, Rhode Island, prominent Black businessman and entrepreneur Benjamin J. Burton is found dead on his kitchen floor with a gunshot to his head, another to his heart, and unchewed bread in his mouth. A perfunctory interview is conducted with his daughters and son-in-law, who lived in the home. All three allege Burton was despondent in the days leading up to his death and told them he did not expect to live much longer. As a result, the medical examiner declares the cause of death to be a clear case of suicide, and Burton is quickly buried without an official inquest. However, when rumors begin circulating in the community that all was not well in the Burton home, the attorney general overrules the medical examiner and orders an exhumation and inquest. Attorney P. J. Galvin challenges the hasty ruling of suicide and believes Burton may have been murdered. The son of an Irish immigrant and the youngest member of the Newport bar, Galvin is thrust into the spotlight by his unexpected appointment to represent the state at the inquest. When the authorities refuse to cooperate with Galvin, he must rely on the help of a gritty New York City Pinkerton Detective and Burton's formidable, widowed sister-in-law, Emily, to investigate. Their investigation suggests that Burton's oldest daughter and his new son-in-law, Allen Dorsey, may be responsible for Burton's death. Dorsey is a brilliant rising star preparing to complete his final year in medical school and is on track to become one of the country's first Black surgeons. As the evidence begins to build against the Dorseys, the community becomes deeply divided over their involvement in Burton's death. Although Galvin succeeds in having Allen Dorsey and his wife Maria arrested, he faces an uphill battle to obtain convictions. The Dorseys engage prominent attorney Colonel William Sheffield, Jr., who has built his career representing Newport's wealthy elite. The son of a United States senator, Sheffield's wealth and political clout enable him to mount a vigorous defense for the Dorseys. Conversely, Galvin's case hinges on the medical testimony of a quirky physician who believes suicide was improbable, if not impossible. After the Dorseys' arrest, and while under her Aunt Emily's care, Burton's seventeen-year-old daughter, Dora, falls dangerously ill with quick consumption. Convinced she is dying, she confesses to Galvin that she acted as a lookout while Dorsey shot her father and reveals her sister to be a willing accomplice. She claims the couple murdered her father to get their hands on his money to fund the remainder of Allen Dorsey's medical school education. However, many in the community believe Dora's confession was coerced by her domineering Aunt Emily, and it does little to change their opinions about the Dorseys' innocence. During the trial, Dora Burton, Galvin's star witness, is subjected to a brutal cross-examination by Sheffield in which he skillfully depicts her as her father's actual murderer. As Maria watches in horror from the defendants' table, she faints from the distress of seeing her beloved little sister unfairly accused of their father's murder. The following morning, unable to bear the guilt any longer, Maria Dorsey unexpectedly admits that her husband killed her father and confesses she was an accomplice, throwing the trial into chaos and humiliating the overconfident Sheffield. Ultimately, the jury finds Allen and Maria Dorsey guilty of murder, and they are sentenced to life in prison. Less than two years later, Allen concocts a plot that involves accusing Maria of incest with her father. From her deathbed, Maria vehemently denies the accusations and his attempt is vilified in the press"--
304 pages
English edition · First published 2026 by Ochre Point Press · ISBN 9781968954000
Be the first to rate this book
Keep track of what you read
Book Nook is a free reading tracker with a 3D bookshelf, a reading timer, challenges with friends and a Reading Wrapped at the end of the year. Add A Harbor of Deceit: A Gilded Age Tale of Money, Murder, and Madness to your shelf in one tap.