Book Nook Join Book Nook

The Letter in the Blue Hymnal (The Last Letter Society)

Riley Jo Bennett

A forgotten hymnal. A vanished pastor’s wife. A child they said never lived.When Hadley Shaw agrees to sort the old hymnals from Mercy Chapel’s choir loft, she expects dust, faded covers, and maybe a few handwritten names tucked between the pages.She does not expect to find a letter sewn into the spine of a worn blue hymnal.The message is decades old, written by Miriam Vale, a pastor’s wife who disappeared from Laurel Ridge in 1962 after a scandal nearly tore Mercy Chapel apart. For years, the town believed Miriam ran from shame. But the letter tells another story—one of a young woman named Ruth Dixon, a baby taken in secret, and a truth hidden where no one thought to look.As Hadley follows Miriam’s clues through hymn numbers, church records, old family papers, and the ruins of a home called Mercy House, she discovers that some people in Laurel Ridge still have reasons to keep the past buried.But Ruth’s final plea is impossible to ignore:Tell my daughter she was loved.With Jonah Hayes beside her and Mercy Chapel’s anniversary approaching, Hadley must decide how far to dig when the truth could wound the living as much as it vindicates the dead.Rich with family secrets, small-town mystery, dual timelines, gentle suspense, and redemptive Christian hope, The Letter in the Blue Hymnal is an emotional inspirational mystery about lost daughters, church silence, old letters, and the grace of truth finally brought into the light.The Letter in the Blue Hymnal is Book Two in The Last Letter Society, a heartfelt Christian fiction series where forgotten letters uncover buried truth and restore broken families.

GenresMystery, Thriller & SuspenseMysteryWomen SleuthsCozyReligion & SpiritualityChristian Books & Bibles

486 pages

English edition · First published 2026 by Independently published · ISBN 9798183960877

Readers also shelved

Be the first to rate this book

Tap or drag across the stars

Keep track of what you read

Book Nook is a free reading tracker with a 3D bookshelf, a reading timer, challenges with friends and a Reading Wrapped at the end of the year. Add The Letter in the Blue Hymnal (The Last Letter Society) to your shelf in one tap.

Join Book Nook Get the app